Josh
Bell
July 25, 2021

BELL CURVE: Grades for each team at the 2021 Draft

The 2021 NHL Draft has come and gone, making dreams come true for 223 prospects from around the globe.

While it will be years until we know who the real winners and losers of this draft are, it’s an interesting exercise to provide some instant analysis and grades regarding the various NHL team’s performance in the draft.

Given the impact of COVID-19 on the hockey world, this year more than ever had many surprises throughout the annual event. Players went much higher than expected, such as Tyler Boucher to the Ottawa Senators at No. 10, and some players found themselves sliding down further than anticipated, as Aatu Raty did, getting drafted at 52nd overall to the New York Islanders.

Now that we know every team’s draft class, we can begin to analyze the selections and the team’s overall draft class. Of course, there’s a lot to factor into this, such as how the picks occurred versus the FCHockey top-300 ranking, teams that addressed needs or consistently attempted to draft the best player available, or the reliance on overage prospects. Trading up or down for certain players can also impact the final grade for every team. 

With all that in mind, FCHockey has the final grades and analysis from all 32 teams in the 2021 NHL Draft.

Anaheim Ducks: B+

Best Selection: Sasha Pastujov (66th)

Mason McTavish was the big add for the Ducks at the No. 3 spot, but there is some question as to whether this was the best possible selection for them. Still, he should become a solid NHLer. They landed some big steals with Olen Zellweger and Sasha Pastujov, the latter of which was projected as a first/high-second rounder. Their final pick of Kyle Kukkonen could be a sneaky good pick as well.

Arizona Coyotes: C+

Best Selection: Dylan Guenther (9th)

The Coyotes made a big splash ahead of the draft with the Oliver Ekman-Larsson trade, adding the No. 9 pick after losing theirs as punishment for NHL Combine violations. They added the best player available in Dylan Guenther at that spot, who immediately becomes the best forward in their system. They then grabbed the son of a Coyote legender, Josh Doan, a breakout overager from the Chicago Steel. They ended up betting big on re-entries, taking two more. Taking swings on Ilya Fedotov and Manix Landry look promising. 

Boston Bruins: B

Best Selection: Fabian Lysell (21st)

Fabian Lysell is the focus here, widely considered a top-10 prospect in the public sphere. A highly-skilled winger with a ton of speed, this is a good value selection. Brett Harrison is also an excellent value pick at No. 85. In the later rounds, taking a swing on OHL defender Ryan Mast could be interesting as he didn’t play this season and the selections of Andre Gasseau and Ty Gallagher are two of the better value selections in the seventh round. 

Buffalo Sabres: A-

Best Selection: Owen Power (1st)

The Sabres did as expected here, selecting defender Owen Power with the No. 1 selection, who should become a solid 2/3D behind Rasmus Dahlin. They bet big on high-skill, high-ceiling players, drafting Isak Rosen, Prokhor Poltapov, and Alexander Kisakov before the end of the second. In the later rounds, QMJHL forwards Oliver Nadeau and Viljami Marjala both show high potential, as does Swedish forward William Von Barnekow. This was a strong draft for the Sabres who restocked the prospect cupboard in a big way.

Calgary Flames: B+

Best Selection: Cole Jordan (141st)

With Matthew Coronato, the Flames take one of the most competitive players in the class, with a nose for getting into the high-danger areas. Their next pick of William Stromgren also could turn into a solid NHLer although he is fairly raw. Picking up Cole Jordan down in the fifth round is one of the biggest draft-day steals, an intelligent defender and strong skater.

Carolina Hurricanes: A-

Best Selection: Aleksi Heimosalmi (44th)

Surprise, surprise, the Hurricanes had a good draft. This year, some savvy trades turned the 27th, 59th, and 123rd picks into seven selections. With those picks, they went all-in on upside, no matter the floor. High school defender Scott Morrow was their first pick, one of the best skaters in the class with impressive transition and offensive skills. Finns Aleksi Heimosalmi and Ville Koivunen are two more prospects with high-end skill. Jackson Blake, Aidan Hreschuk, Justin Robidas, and Robert Orr also look like strong contenders to be future NHLers.

Chicago Blackhawks: C-

Best Selection: Victor Stjernborg (108th)

The Blackhawks bet big on overagers in this draft, a risky decision that comes with limited upside. With their first selection at the end of the 32nd round, they drafted shutdown defender Nolan Allan, reaching fairly significantly for him. They did draft Kirby Dach’s younger brother, Colton Dach, which is a nice story but again, possibly a bit too high. Their strong selections came in the fourth round with defender Ethan Del Mastro and Victor Stjernborg

Colorado Avalanche: C+

Best Selection: Oskar Olausson (28th)

With just four selections in the draft, there’s only so much the Avalanche could do. They started off strong, taking skilled winger Oskar Olausson who should provide future secondary scoring. They bet on upside with USNTDP defender Sean Behrens, who has some work to do but has shown flashes of strong play. Their next two picks were used on 20-year-olds Andrei Buyalsky and Cale Makar’s brother, Taylor Makar.

Columbus Blue Jackets: A

Best Selection: Kent Johnson (5th)

The Blue Jackets have one of the best draft classes of any team, looking through an instant lens. Kent Johnson and Cole Sillinger are two of the most creative, offensive players in this class, and Corson Ceulemans brings a mobile, physical game to the Columbus system. Stanislav Svozil and Guillaume Richard could both become NHL defenders, and James Malatesta and Martin Rysavy have the competitive edge that you wouldn’t want to bet against. This was an extremely strong weekend for the Blue Jackets.

Dallas Stars: A

Best Selection: Logan Stankoven (47th)

Another team that had an excellent draft, the only change that could really improve the weekend is swapping their selections of Wyatt Johnston and Logan Stankoven. Either way, these two forwards are two of the highest-motor players in the class, who could both become middle-six NHLers. Ayrton Martino is another promising forward with sky-high skill. On the back end, both Artyom Grushnikov and Jack Bar have the makings of NHL defenders. This could be a game-changing draft for the Stars.

Detroit Red Wings: B+

Best Selection: Shai Buium (36th)

The Red Wings continue to show that they love their big defenders, drafting Simon Edvinsson with the sixth overall pick and then adding Shai Buium in the second round. Both look to be on the path to wear the red and white. They traded up in the first to draft Sebastian Cossa, which was surprising given that Jesper Wallstedt was still on the board. Some of their swings in the later rounds could pan out as NHL regulars as well, such as Red Savage and Liam Dower Nilsson.

Edmonton Oilers: D+

Best Selection: Xavier Bourgault (22nd)

The Oilers started the draft off well, landing mature, skilled centerman Xavier Bourgault in the first round. Matvei Petrov is a great value pick down at No. 180 as a winger that loves to shoot the puck, but he has his work cut out for him to become an NHLer. However, the Oilers other selections seem like they reached at this point, highlighted by German defender Luca Munzenberger in the third round, who would be better served as a late-round target.

Florida Panthers: B-

Best Selection: Matthew Samoskevich (24th)

The Panthers kicked off their draft by selecting Matthew Samoskevich, a forward with top-six potential. Evan Nause is a great value selection down at No. 56, who could have top-four upside. Russians Vladislav Lukashevich and Kirill Gerasimyuk are also good selections, especially at where they got them. Behind Samoskevich, it’s not a flashy class, but there could be some NHL regulars here.

Los Angeles Kings: B+

Best Selection: Brandt Clarke (8th)

Like the Hurricanes, good drafts are pretty much expected for the Kings. With just four selections, they didn’t add as much as they have in past drafts, but they made it count. This is highlighted by Brandt Clarke, an offensive defender that was in the discussion for first-overall. It was surprising how far Francesco Pinelli fell, but it was right into the laps of the Kings at No. 42. They also added Samuel Helenius and Kirill Kirsanov, two boom-or-bust prospects but with promising ceilings.

Minnesota Wild: B+

Best Selection: Jesper Wallstedt (20th)

The Wild started off their draft extremely strong, trading up to land highly-touted goaltender Jesper Wallstedt at 20th overall. Six picks later, they selected defender Carson Lambos. With both of these selections, Minnesota added players that have been in the conversation of first-overall at one point this season. Their excellent draft continued in the second round, selecting homegrown defender Jack Peart. Their draft wasn’t as exciting after these three picks, but there are some gambles that could pay off.

Montreal Canadiens: No Grade

Best Selection: Oliver Kapanen (64th)

The Canadiens’ first selection of Logan Mailloux is highly controversial and deserving of an F grade.

The rest of their draft class after this pick, however, was quite good. They put a heavy emphasis on the QMJHL, with Riley Kidney, Joshua Roy, and Xavier Simoneau having real NHL potential. Oliver Kapanen was one of the top Finnish players available, and at No. 64 was an excellent value selection. Dmitri Kostenko and William Trudeau also look to have the tools to reach the NHL, while betting on goaltender Joe Vrbetic in the seventh round is a good gamble. Taking away the Mailloux selection, the Canadiens would have had a B+ grade.

Nashville Predators: A-

Best Selection: Fyodor Svechkov (19th)

The Predators are entering a turning point in their organization, and they did well in this draft to help lead into the future. With two picks in the first round, they landed one of the best two-way centers in the class in Fyodor Svechkov and then the highly-skilled – and slightly reckless – Zachary L’Heureux. They then turned their attention to the blue line, selecting Anton Olsson, Ryan Ufko, and Jack Matier. Even with their final pick of Simon Knak, there’s NHL upside here. This is a very strong class. 

New Jersey Devils: B

Best Selection: Luke Hughes (4th)

The Devils started off their draft early at the fourth-overall pick, uniting brother Jack Hughes and Luke Hughes. Their pick later in the first is slightly questionable, as it is a bit high, in OHLer Chase Stillman. Samu Salminen hasn’t been a favourite of FCHockey’s scouts, but his value is solid at 68th overall. The later picks are all fairly big swings, but the first three selections that the Devils made should become NHLers.

New York Islanders: B

Best Selection: Aatu Raty (52nd)

The Islanders didn’t have a selection until No. 52, but they made it count, taking a big swing on Aatu Raty. If Raty, once widely considered the top prospect in the class, reaches his ceiling this could be the biggest steal of the draft. Goaltender Tristan Lennox is one of the stronger goalies available and the bets on Finns Eetu Liukas and Aleksi Malinen are promising. Without having a top-50 pick, this is a good haul for the Islanders

New York Rangers: C

Best Selection: Brennan Othmann (16th)

The Rangers started the draft well, landing sharpshooter Brennan Othmann at No. 16. Their draft will likely rely heavily on that pick panning out though, as after they took some swings, including Jayden Grubbe, Kalle Vaisanen, and Hank Kempf. Ryder Korczak and Brody Lamb could be promising gambles, and goaltender Talyn Boyko shows potential. Overall, the Rangers likely left some value and skill on the table, but there’s some upside in this class.

Ottawa Senators: D-

Best Selection: Carson Latimer (123rd)

The Senators have proven in their drafting record that they blaze their own path in the draft, and they’ve proven the public wrong many times. They could very well do it here too, as they put in more work and have more knowledge than the public sphere. The instant analysis of this draft doesn’t bode well for Ottawa, starting with a big reach at 10th overall with Tyler Boucher. This became a theme in the draft, making big reaches or even taking players not on the public’s radar. Zack Ostapchuk and Benjamin Roger seem a bit high in the second round. However, Carson Latimer could be an interesting name to follow as he develops. The Senators are building a team that other teams hate to play against, which is valuable, but you do need high-skill, top-line players to balance that out. 

Philadelphia Flyers: C-

Best Selection: Samu Tuomaala (46th)

The Flyers didn’t get their draft started until the 46th selection after trading their first rounder to the Sabres, making it worth it by picking sniper Samu Tuomaala. Tuomaala works best in the offensive zone, and is a dual threat with his shot and his playmaking. Goaltender Alexei Kolosov is a bit high at No. 78, especially with Benjamin Gaudreau still on the board, but he’s a mature, promising netminder. Ty Murchison has potential, but again, the pick is a bit of a reach. This class will likely rely on Tuomaala to determine its value.

Pittsburgh Penguins: D

Best Selection: Tristan Broz (58th)

The Penguins might very well be allergic to first round picks, however they do have a pretty good record of turning mid-round players into NHLers. The Penguins had to wait until No. 58 to make their first pick, and they selected highly skilled forward Tristan Broz. After that, the picks are questionable. Isaac Belliveau has some real issues defending and in his decision making. These two picks were their only selections outside of the seventh round. Daniel Laatsch is a name to watch from the seventh, but this class really depends on Broz.

San Jose Sharks: C+

Best Selection: William Eklund (7th)

William Eklund fell right into the laps of the Sharks at seventh overall, as he was in the conversation for No. 1. Eklund is one of the most NHL-ready prospects in the class, and could be playing in California sooner rather than later. They waited until the 81st pick for their next selection, landing one of the best goaltenders available in Benjamin Gaudreau. This might just be one of the best value picks in the draft. After this, Ethan Cardwell and Liam Gilmartin have some potential, although there are a number of other picks they made that don’t have a ton of upside.

Seattle Kraken: C

Best Selection: Matthew Beniers (2nd)

The Kraken kicked off their first-ever NHL Draft as expected, selecting top-forward Matthew Beniers to build their prospect pool around. After this pick though, the Kraken’s draft was less than exciting. They made Ryker Evans the first overager off the board, much earlier than expected. Ryan Winterton could be a good depth player as well. Overall, the Kraken left a lot of skill on the table in their first draft, but Beniers could be good enough to carry the class.

St. Louis Blues: C+

Best Selection: Simon Robertsson (71st)

The Blues couldn’t do too much in the draft with just four selections. The landed Zachary Bolduc at No. 17, a goal-scoring forward with excellent reliability in his own end. They then landed one of the best value picks in the draft, taking Swedish winger Simon Robertsson down in the third round after widely being considered a first rounder. They took two swings on Tyson Galloway and Ivan Vorobyov in the later rounds, so it will be on Bolduc and Robertsson to lead this class.

Tampa Bay Lightning: D

Best Selection: Dylan Duke (126th)

The Lightning had to wait longer than any team for their first pick and they used the 96th selection on USNTDP defender Roman Schmidt. This was a bit high for the defender, who really struggled this season. They stuck with the USNTDP for their next pick, stealing Dylan Duke after he fell two rounds further than expected. They finished their draft with some gambles that will have their work cut out to be NHLers. Duke is the key player of this class, but this could be an overall weak group for Tampa Bay.

Toronto Maple Leafs: C+

Best Selection: Matthew Knies (57th)

The Maple Leafs had just three picks in the draft and didn’t add any extra, so options were limited. They selected highly skilled forward Matthew Knies at No. 57. They then had to wait nearly 100 selections to No. 153, selecting undersized, promising forward Ty Voit. Their final pick was goaltender Vyacheslav Peksa, a name not on the radar in the public sphere. Knies will be the key player here.

Vancouver Canucks: C-

Best Selection: Lucas Forsell (201st)

While Danila Klimovich turned heads at the Under-18s, this is a surprising pick up at No. 41. It’s a big swing for the Canucks first pick of the draft, that looks like a high-risk, high-reward option. Goaltender Aku Koskenvuo has shown some potential this season, and Connor Lockhart might be one of the best skaters in the class, and Lucas Forsell has been a favourite of FCHockey scouts, but the Canucks could only do so much with one pick in the first four rounds.

Vegas Golden Knights: C

Best Selection: Zach Dean (30th)

Zach Dean is an excellent first selection for the Golden Knights first-round pick, who has top-six potential, although the middle-six is more likely. Daniil Chayka was promising in his D-1 season, but really struggled this season. He is a rangy defender, but this is a bit of a risk. Vegas’ class will rely heavily on these two becoming NHLers as their other picks are big gambles. 

Washington Capitals: C-

Best Selection: Brent Johnson (80th)

The Capitals waited patiently until the 55th pick in the draft to make their first selection, landing very promising defender Vincent Iorio. They followed that up with another strong defender Brent Johnson, a great value pick at No. 80. The remaining selections aren’t the most exciting, so the weight will rest on the shoulders of the top-two draft picks.

Winnipeg Jets: B+

Best Selection: Chaz Lucius (18th)

The Jets had only four selections to make in the draft, but they did very well with what they had. Landing Chaz Lucius, a goal-scorer that was in the top-10 conversation, at 18 is one of the best value picks in the first round. They followed that up with Nikita Chibrikov at 50th overall, another prospect that was considered a first rounder. The took a swing on Belarussian defender Dmitri Kuzmin, a purely upside pick. While small, this could be a strong class for the Jets.


NHL Draft grades, by grade

Columbus Blue Jackets: A
Dallas Stars: A
Buffalo Sabres: A-
Carolina Hurricanes: A-
Nashville Predators: A-
Anaheim Ducks: B+
Calgary Flames: B+
Detroit Red Wings: B+
Los Angeles Kings: B+
Minnesota Wild: B+
Winnipeg Jets: B+
Boston Bruins: B
New Jersey Devils: B
New York Islanders: B
Florida Panthers: B-
Arizona Coyotes: C+
Colorado Avalanche: C+
San Jose Sharks: C+
St. Louis Blues: C+
Toronto Maple Leafs: C+
New York Rangers: C
Seattle Kraken: C
Vegas Golden Knights: C
Chicago Blackhawks: C-
Philadelphia Flyers: C-
Vancouver Canucks: C-
Washington Capitals: C-
Edmonton Oilers: D+
Pittsburgh Penguins: D
Tampa Bay Lightning: D
Ottawa Senators: D-
Montreal Canadiens: No grade

More Stories

September 25, 2024

Hagens tops FCHockey’s Preliminary ranking for the 2025 NHL Draft

September 5, 2024

How Adam Benak is able to impact the game so significantly despite his size

August 22, 2024

Matthew Schaefer is speeding his way to the top of the list in 2025

Get insider content and scouting reports you can’t find anywhere else.

Sign up now