Aaron Vickers | FCHockey

Kareem

Elshafey

May 7, 2025

Post-Lottery mock for the 2025 NHL Draft

The New York Islanders can’t miss with Matthew Schaefer.

The Islanders, who won the 2025 NHL Draft Lottery, will be on the clock when the 2025 NHL Draft gets underway next month and, while the likelihood of them snapping up the defenseman will be debated over the next number of weeks, there’s no missing on the consensus No. 1 pick.

“He’s a bonafide first-overall selection and, despite not playing the back-half of the season because of an injury sustained at the World Juniors in December, the shine hasn’t come close to coming off,” FCHockey crossover scout Aaron Vickers said of Schaefer, who topped FCHockey’s Spring ranking for the 2025 draft and will close the season at no. 1 in the soon-to-be-released Final ranking.

“There’s little Schaefer doesn’t do at an elite level for a junior-aged defenseman despite being one of the youngest members of the 2025 draft. There isn’t another prospect in the draft that’s as likely to impact an NHL team the way Schaefer currently projects.”

So, will Schaefer go first overall?

Here’s a look at our post-NHL Draft Lottery mock of the 2025 NHL Draft.

1. NEW YORK ISLANDERS: MATTHEW SCHAEFER | D | ERIE (OHL)

The New York Islanders select Schaefer of the Erie Otters with the 1st pick of the 2025 NHL Draft.

Schaefer has been sidelined with a collarbone injury suffered at the World Juniors, but that shouldn’t affect his status as the No. 1 prospect in this year’s draft. With the Otters, he tallied 11 goals and 23 assists in just 26 games. He was the standout player at the CHL-USA Prospects Challenge, and during his brief World Juniors appearance, he looked like Canada’s best defenseman.

He projects as a potential No. 1 defenseman who can play in all situations, headlined by elite skating, offensive instincts, and an exceptionally intelligent defensive game. By winning the lottery, the Islanders have dramatically reshaped their prospect pool. They selected Cole Eiserman last year and acquired Calum Ritchie at the trade deadline. Adding Schaefer to the blue line and setting up a potential pairing with Noah Dobson is an exciting development.

An added bonus: he’s one of the youngest players in this draft class, only a couple of weeks inside the cutoff for eligibility.

“Schaefer is a gifted two-way defenseman who has a massive impact on games for Erie. He is an incredibly smooth skater with a great stride, allowing him to cover the ice efficiently. His edgework, pivots in transition, and lateral mobility make him highly effective in all areas of the game. His hockey sense is off the charts—he reads plays exceptionally well and has a strong understanding of when to pinch to keep plays alive and when to sit back.” – FCHockey regional scout Mike Kennedy

2. SAN JOSE SHARKS: MICHAEL MISA | C | SAGINAW (OHL)

The San Jose Sharks select Michael Misa of the Saginaw Spirit with the 2nd pick of the 2025 NHL Draft.

Misa was the best player in the OHL this year, posting a staggering 62 goals and 72 assists for 134 points in 65 games. He is versatile, capable of playing both center and wing, which could give the team flexibility when deploying him and Will Smith behind Macklin Celebrini.

He may also be the most NHL-ready player in this year’s draft.

“Misa is a versatile and dangerous forward with elite agility and vision, complementing his high-end skating ability and impressive puck skills. A household name for a few seasons, he has taken a significant step forward in consistency and production this season. His elite edgework and quickness allow him to create space in board battles and high-traffic areas, giving him time to survey for passing lanes. He excels at carrying the puck in transition, using his speed to maintain possession in the offensive zone and drive play for his linemates. Misa’s patience and vision with the puck enable him to make difficult plays through the middle lane, and he is a dual shooting or passing threat from the wing on the power play.” – FCHockey regional scout Joseph Aleong

3. CHICAGO BLACKHAWKS: CALEB DESNOYERS| C | MONCTON (QMJHL)

The Chicago Blackhawks select Caleb Desnoyers of the Moncton Wildcats with the 3rd pick of the 2025 NHL Draft.

Desnoyers is a complete, 200-foot center who led the QMJHL’s top team with 84 points (35 goals, 49 assists) in 56 games and has continued his production through the playoffs. His attention to detail is impressive, and while he may not possess the raw talent of some other prospects, there’s no doubt he can generate offense with his underrated playmaking ability.

Desnoyers projects as a rock-solid second-line center—exactly the type of player every contending NHL team needs. James Hagens was considered here, but with Chicago already boasting several smaller forwards, selecting Desnoyers makes sense. His ability to take on a shutdown role and ease the burden on Connor Bedard down the middle provides both immediate value and long-term balance.

“Desnoyers is a big-bodied, intelligent center who excels as a playmaker with excellent vision and a deft passing touch, consistently finding teammates in dangerous positions with smart, well-timed dishes. While not a flashy or dynamic offensive catalyst, he possesses underrated creativity and silky hands when needed, occasionally catching opponents — and even teammates — off guard with subtle but effective plays. Desnoyers’ offensive game is typically straightforward yet highly effective, as he uses his strong skating, with a long, efficient stride and excellent edgework, to control pace, create space, and whip accurate passes in transition. Defensively, he’s very responsible and reliable, never cheating for offense and always providing support by staying above the puck, even in the offensive zone. His size and mobility make him a puck magnet in all three zones, and he dominates board battles with consistency, using his frame to protect possession and outmuscle opponents.” – Vickers

4. UTAH MAMMOTH: PORTER MARTONE | RW | BRAMPTON (OHL)

The Utah Mammoth select Porter Martone of the Brampton Steelheads with the 4th pick of the 2025 NHL Draft.

Martone is a big winger with the kind of game opponents hate to play against but teammates love to have on their side. He’s a true power forward who thrives in the tough areas below the dots, combining physicality with legitimate offensive skill. He projects as a potential foundational piece for any organization willing to be patient with his development.

Although he cooled off after a blazing start, Martone still finished the season with an impressive 98 points in 57 games. His combination of size, grit, and scoring ability makes him a valuable asset in today’s NHL. I like the fit with Utah, where he could complement skilled forwards like Clayton Keller and Logan Cooley by bringing a heavier, more rugged element to their top six.

“He can set up plays effectively, score important goals, lead naturally, and play a physical yet smart game. He is a highly projectable player who can be used in any situation and perform at a high level. There isn’t really an area in his game that’s lacking. Martone can do it all — and he does. Every team in the NHL is looking for these potential unicorns: big players who can handle every situation, play with speed and physicality, and create constant pressure.” – FCHockey Chief scout Samuel Tirpak

5. NASHVILLE PREDATORS: JAMES HAGENS | C | BOSTON COLLEGE (NCAA)

The Nashville Predators select James Hagens from Boston College with the 5th pick of the 2025 NHL Draft.

Hagens is no longer the top-ranked prospect in FCHockey’s book, but he should still be considered an exciting talent. While he didn’t dominate during his freshman season at Boston College—particularly in terms of goal scoring, with 11 goals and 26 assists in 37 games—he remains one of the premier playmakers in this draft class. He also delivered a strong performance for Team USA during their gold medal run at the World Juniors, reinforcing his value on the international stage.

Nashville previously added David Edstrom in a trade, but the organization still lacks depth and youth down the middle. Hagens would help address that need, offering high-end vision and passing ability from the center position.

“As dominant as he is controlling the puck, he’s got an advanced off-the-puck game as well. His eyes are always glued to the puck, and his body is always facing it too, making it easy for him to quickly make a play when the puck gets near him. He sees openings before they reveal themselves and weaves in and out of traffic gracefully, impacting plays at all times. Hagens is a real maestro with the disc, manipulating defenses with his high-end mobility and puckhandling. He’s a cerebral distributor who serves crisp and firm outlets with pinpoint accuracy, routinely finding crafty ways to feed his teammates, whether it’s with between-the-legs passes while facing the boards, tip passes, area passes, etc. He generates and exploits switches and movement so well in the offensive zone, doing so until there’s an opening, on which he instantly creates high-grade chances for his teammates.” – FCHockey chief regional scout Joey Fortin Boulay

6. PHILADELPHIA FLYERS: ANTON FRONDELL | C | DJURGARDENS IF (SHL)

The Philadelphia Flyers select Anton Frondell of Djurgardens IF with the 6th pick of the 2025 NHL Draft.

There was a point early in the draft season when Frondell appeared to be slipping out of the top 10. However, he has elevated his game significantly since the new year and has reestablished himself as a legitimate top-10 prospect. At his best, Frondell is a force in the offensive zone cycle, using his strength and puck protection to wear down defenders.

He pairs that power-forward presence with a lethal one-timer, solid playmaking skills, and strong offensive instincts—all of which justify an early first-round selection despite the up-and-down nature of his season. The Flyers are in search of a franchise center to pair with Matvei Michkov, and Frondell could be that player. His blend of size, skill, and scoring touch offers an enticing fit for a team looking to build a dynamic top-six core.

“In the offensive end, he forechecks well and can play a physical game. He also positions himself really well away from the puck to open himself up for quality scoring chances. He drives toward the back post off the rush really well also, which allows him to be a threat in that area. That’s all due to his skating ability. While he isn’t the fastest skater, he has strong edges and agility that allow him to make cuts, slow down, speed up, and be an overall efficient mover. With the puck, Frondell plays it smart. He has good vision, which allows him to exploit defensive mistakes when they appear. However, he takes what the defense gives him, getting the puck to teammates in space, then moving himself to get into better position.” – FCHockey crossover scout Kyle Pereira

7. BOSTON BRUINS: JAKE O’BRIEN | C | BRANTFORD (OHL)

The Boston Bruins select Jake O’Brien of the Brantford Bulldogs with the 7th pick of the 2025 NHL Draft.

Jake O’Brien has done a lot to elevate his stock this season, recording 32 goals and 66 assists in 66 games and cementing his status as one of the most dangerous passers in the draft. His vision and ability to distribute the puck make him a dynamic offensive threat, particularly in transition and on the power play.

O’Brien also brings the physical profile NHL teams covet—a big, right-shot center with the potential to anchor a top-six role. However, filling out his frame and continuing to develop his strength will be essential to fully unlocking his upside at the next level. For the Bruins, who arguably possess the weakest prospect pool in the league, O’Brien would be a valuable addition. They are still in search of a young, top-six center to help lead their next generation, and O’Brien fits that mold well.

“O’Brien is an extremely crafty two-way center with a high hockey IQ and a strong ability to read and anticipate plays. Both his offensive and defensive instincts shine throughout the course of a game, displaying his understanding of space and timing. He possesses a powerful skating stride that allows him to accelerate effectively through the neutral zone and initiate the attack. Additionally, he’s a gifted playmaker who distributes the puck with precision and intent. O’Brien threads passes through traffic and executes hard, cross-ice feeds to set up teammates in high-scoring areas.” – Kennedy

8. SEATTLE KRAKEN: KASAHWN AITCHESON | D | BARRIE (OHL)

The Seattle Kraken select Kashawn Aitcheson of the Barrie Colts with the 8th pick in the 2025 NHL Draft.

The Kraken are an interesting case heading into the draft. They’ve used several recent first-round picks on forwards, which has left their defensive prospect pool notably thin. Aitcheson addresses that need. He’s a dynamic, hard-nosed defenseman who plays with a physical edge, consistently delivering big hits while maintaining sound positioning in his own zone.

Offensively, Aitcheson took a significant step forward this season with the Barrie Colts, showcasing a strong shot and the confidence to jump into the rush. While there’s room for debate about whether he’s the best player available at this point in the draft, organizational depth becomes a key tiebreaker. Radim Mrtka, who plays in Seattle’s backyard, could be a logical pick as well, but Aitcheson is ranked higher by FC Hockey and brings a toolkit that aligns well with the Kraken’s long-term needs on the blue line.

Selecting Aitcheson helps restore balance to the pipeline and gives Seattle a defenseman who can play with bite, skate well, and contribute offensively—a valuable combination as the team continues to build a competitive foundation.

“Defensively, Aitcheson is a standout due to his physicality and solid technical skills. He uses his size effectively to outmuscle opponents, win puck battles, and protect his team’s zone. Additionally, his defensive toolkit is impressive — he combines strong stick-checking with shot-blocking abilities, creating a well-rounded, reliable defensive presence. Aitcheson also contributes offensively, showing a touch of creativity and confidence on the power play. He can quarterback from the point, displaying a quick and powerful one-timer when opportunities arise. He’s not afraid to take a shot when he has an opening, nor does he shy away from attempting challenging passes to set up plays.” – FCHockey regional scout Blake McGuire

9. BUFFALO SABRES: VICTOR EKLUND | LW | DJURGARDENS IF (SHL)

The Buffalo Sabres select Victor Eklund of Djurgardens IF with the 9th pick of the 2025 NHL Draft.

The Sabres are back picking in the top 10 once again, and as a result, they’ve built a strong and well-rounded prospect pool. At this spot, Eklund stands out as the best player available and the type of forward who can seamlessly fit into any lineup. His game is built on relentless effort, excellent skating, and a strong two-way presence.

Eklund plays with a high motor, consistently hounding pucks and winning battles across all three zones. He complements that tenacity with the offensive skill set required to justify a top-10 selection, showing creativity, vision, and the ability to finish plays himself. His versatility and work ethic make him a coach’s dream, capable of adapting to a variety of roles while still impacting the game at a high level.

For Buffalo, Eklund represents a safe yet high-upside addition—a player who can contribute in multiple areas while growing into a potential top-six role.

“Eklund is an electric presence every time he steps on the ice. He battles hard, is fast, difficult to contain, and a strong offensive player all around. What stands out about his game is the combination of his compete level and skill — a perfect recipe for a long and successful NHL career. His game is high energy, marked by relentless effort, engaging in every battle, and working hard all game long.” – Tirpak

10. ANAHEIM DUCKS: BRADY MARTIN | C | SAULT STE. MARIE (OHL)

The Anaheim Ducks select Brady Martin of the Sault Ste. Marie Greyhounds with the 10th pick of the 2025 NHL Draft.

Martin is coming off a strong performance at the U18 Worlds and fits the mold of a player Ducks general manager Pat Verbeek is likely to covet. He plays with a relentless motor, punishing opponents with physicality while bringing a consistent work ethic every time he steps on the ice. His game is built on intensity and effort, but he also has the skill to contribute offensively, particularly when driving play through the middle.

Martin’s combination of grit, competitiveness, and ability to play center makes him a valuable asset in a league that increasingly values players who can do it all. He may not be the flashiest prospect, but his versatility and physical edge make him a compelling option for a team like Anaheim, which continues to build a hard-nosed identity.

“Martin is an absolute menace of a forward because of his physicality, compete, and skill. He plays a power game. His motor is always running and he rarely passes up an opportunity to throw a check and genuinely looks like he enjoys the physical side of the game. A hard competitor with skill makes for a great combination, and that’s what is almost always on display in Martin’s game. What makes it more frustrating for defenders, who already have to play with a head on a swivel when he hops the boards, is the fact that he’s got that layer of skill. Martin has a pretty solid set of hands that couples well with a really good set of wheels. That combination allows him to drive wide and take pucks hard to the net — which, of course, is something he seemingly enjoys.” – Vickers

11. PITTSBURGH PENGUINS: CULLEN POTTER | LW | ARIZONA STATE (NCAA)

The Pittsburgh Penguins select Cullen Potter from Arizona State with the 11th pick in the 2025 NHL Draft.

Potter may be the best skater in this year’s draft class, and he uses that dynamic mobility as a launchpad for creating offense. His skating is paired with high-end puck skills and creativity in possession, making him one of the most exciting offensive talents available. That combination of speed and finesse has earned him a prominent spot on our rankings list, with the potential for significant upside at the NHL level.

While Potter doesn’t play a particularly physical game, he’s not deterred by physicality and shows a willingness to compete in contested areas. There are fair questions about whether his offensive production will translate as effectively against NHL defenders, but his raw talent and confidence suggest he’s capable of adjusting and continuing to generate scoring chances.

This pick has the hallmarks of a player who would interest Kyle Dubas—skilled, mobile, and analytics-friendly. Although Jackson Smith was also considered here due to his more well-rounded profile, Potter’s ceiling and game-breaking ability make him an intriguing option. For a team looking to inject speed and skill into its lineup, Potter offers exactly that.

“Potter is a speedy forward whose game revolves around his complete skating ability. In transition, he uses his speed to fly through the neutral zone, gain entry into the offensive zone and create chances in a variety of ways. He can take defenders wide before driving toward the net or slam on the brakes just inside the blue line before finding a trailer in the middle of the ice. Additionally, his lateral quickness and agility are just as impressive, allowing him to cut into the middle of the ice from the wing. After activating that speed, he’s able to thread passes across the seam or to high-danger areas throughout the first period. Even though he’s a smaller player, Potter succeeds in tight areas in the offensive zone, primarily due to his edgework. He can elude opponents below the dots to create space, which he then parleys into a scoring chance for himself or a teammate.” – FCHockey regional scout Kareem Elshafey

12. NEW YORK RANGERS: LYNDEN LAKOVIC | LW | MOOSE JAW (WHL)

The New York Rangers select Lynden Lakovic of the Moose Jaw Warriors with the 12th pick of the 2025 NHL Draft.

Lakovic is a 6-foot-4 winger who defies traditional expectations for a player of his size, favoring a finesse and skill-based game over a physically imposing style. He’s an excellent skater for his frame, showing fluid mobility and impressive edge work, which allows him to carry speed through the neutral zone and become a significant threat in transition.

One of Lakovic’s standout traits is his ability to protect the puck, using his reach and skating stride to shield defenders and maintain possession under pressure. Offensively, he boasts a powerful shot and near-elite puck-handling ability, giving him the tools to both finish plays and create opportunities for teammates. His playmaking has taken a notable step forward as the season has progressed, adding another dimension to his game and increasing his value as a dual-threat forward.

Lakovic’s combination of size, skill, and offensive upside makes him a highly intriguing prospect. If he continues to refine his game and develop more consistency, particularly in high-traffic areas, he could evolve into a top-six winger with game-breaking potential.

“His ability to execute subtle, high-skill plays in tight areas stands out, supported by a soft touch with the puck and quick hands. His quick release and accuracy make him a dangerous finisher, though he has also flashed some playmaking ability, hinting at a more well-rounded offensive toolkit. Whether it’s slipping a pass through traffic or pickpocketing an opponent, he consistently showcases strong puck skills. Lakovic’s skating is aided by his long legs, giving him a fluid, rangy stride that is effective in transition. While he doesn’t come across as the fastest player, his stride efficiency and puck-protection skills make him hard to contain when carrying the puck up ice.” – Vickers.

13. DETROIT RED WINGS: JACKSON SMITH | D | TRI-CITY (WHL)

The Detroit Red Wings select Jackson Smith of the Tri-City Americans with the 13th pick of the 2025 NHL Draft.

There aren’t many players more enjoyable to watch than Smith. He possesses a rare blend of size and high-end mobility that perfectly aligns with the demands of the modern NHL. Standing out as a smooth-skating defenseman with a strong physical presence, Smith uses his frame effectively and excels at defending the rush with poise and precision.

This season, he tallied 11 goals and added 43 assists in 68 games, numbers that reflect his comfort with the puck and his growing offensive instincts. His willingness to activate off the blue line and join the rush speaks to his confidence and understanding of when to push the pace. While he’s not yet a fully polished offensive defenseman, the foundation is there for further development.

What stands between Smith and reaching his full potential is the mental aspect of the game—making quicker reads under pressure and improving decision-making in tight situations. If that part of his game continues to evolve, he could emerge as a top-four NHL defenseman with true two-way impact.

Smith’s combination of tools—size, skating, and puck skill—makes him one of the more intriguing defensemen in this class, and with the right development path, he could become a cornerstone on the back end for years to come.

“Smith is a two-way defenseman who has all the measurables you want from an NHL defenseman. He’s got great size and the puck-moving and skating ability to go with it. He has true four-way mobility and can change directions exceptionally well. This really helps him on breakouts and zone entries as he can weave through traffic and move to the next level. This is, of course, partly due to his puck-handling as well. He really can keep the puck on a string while dancing through the neutral zone. I was particularly impressed by his rush defending, especially on odd-man rushes. He looked calm and poised despite being in difficult situations.” – FCHockey crossover scout Jacob Roth

14. COLUMBUS BLUE JACKETS: RADIM MRTKA | D | SEATTLE (WHL)

The Columbus Blue Jackets select Radim Mrtka of the Seattle Thunderbirds with the 14th pick of the 2025 NHL Draft.

Mrtka is a towering 6-foot-6 right-shot defenseman who has seen his draft stock rise steadily since joining the WHL. He moves remarkably well for a player of his size, showing fluid stride mechanics and impressive agility, especially in defensive zone retrievals and transitions. His mobility, combined with his reach and physical presence, gives him significant upside as a shutdown defender at the next level.

Beyond his defensive capabilities, Mrtka has shown flashes of offensive potential. He makes smart, subtle plays with the puck, whether it’s a timely outlet pass or an activated pinch to keep a play alive. While his offensive game remains secondary, the foundation is in place for further growth in that area. His coordination and timing still need refinement, as he can look a bit awkward at times—likely a byproduct of continuing to grow into his large frame.

With his rare physical attributes and promising development trajectory, it’s easy to envision Mrtka being selected in the top 10. His ceiling as a top-four, right-shot defenseman who can log heavy minutes makes him an appealing asset for any team. Columbus would be a strong fit, as they continue to rebuild their blue line and could benefit from adding a physically imposing presence on the right side. If Mrtka’s game continues to mature, he could become a long-term fixture on an NHL backend.

“Mrtka maintains a good gap and uses his long stick and large frame to block passing lanes or step up on forwards quickly. Because of that, beating Mrtka to the inside is rarely an option. He’s tough to play against down low, as his size makes it incredibly hard to win puck battles or gain positional advantage. While he isn’t physically overpowering with violent hits, he effectively uses his frame to his advantage. However, his poise with the puck under pressure can be inconsistent. At times, he holds onto the puck longer than necessary, and his decision-making isn’t always as quick as desired. For his size, Mrtka is a very mobile defender with impressive straight-line speed, which he uses to activate into rushes and transport the puck effectively during breakouts. Offensively, he’ll surprise you with solid puck-handling skills and playmaking ability, allowing him to contribute both on the rush and in the offensive zone.” – Elshafey

15. VANCOUVER CANUCKS: ROGER MCQUEEN | C | BRANDON (WHL)

The Vancouver Canucks select Roger McQueen of the Brandon Wheat Kings with the 15th pick of the 2025 NHL Draft.

There’s a legitimate argument that, had McQueen remained healthy throughout the season, he’d be in the top-five conversation. After being medically cleared, he returned to action on March 4 but unfortunately missed the final games of Brandon’s playoff run due to another injury setback. The concern around his durability is valid, but so is the excitement surrounding his upside.

McQueen offers a tantalizing blend of size, skill, and skating ability—traits that are hard to find in one package, especially down the middle. When healthy, he shows flashes of dominance, with the potential to become a high-impact top-six center at the NHL level. He can drive play, protect the puck with ease, and generate offense both off the rush and in sustained zone pressure. However, the injury history casts a shadow, and teams will be closely watching his medical reports during the combine.

If McQueen checks out, there’s a strong chance he won’t be available by the 15th pick. For a team like Vancouver, with an organizational need for a future top-six center, McQueen presents a calculated but potentially high-reward swing. Given the physical tools and upside, selecting him here would make sense—provided there’s confidence in his ability to stay healthy and continue his development uninterrupted.

“McQueen is a hulking, right-shot center whose combination of size, puck protection skills, and offensive instincts make him a significant presence whenever he hops over the boards. His elite ability to shield defenders with his frame and maintain possession in tight spaces stands out immediately, and this is complemented by soft hands that allow him to make plays in tight spaces even with a long stick. He demonstrates a strong understanding of time and space, knowing when to distribute quickly or hold onto the puck to create higher-percentage chances, and his one-timer is an absolute weapon, though his wrist shot release needs significant improvement to translate effectively at higher levels. His skating is fluid for his size, utilizing his long stride well despite occasional awkwardness, and he shows promise at the faceoff dot.” – Vickers

16. MONTREAL CANADIENS (VIA CGY): JUSTIN CARBONNEAU | RW | BLAINVILLE-BOISBRIAND (QMJHL)

The Montreal Canadiens select Justin Carbonneau of the Blainville-Boisbriand Armada with the 16th pick in the 2025 NHL Draft.

Carbonneau, with 46 goals and 43 assists in 62 games, stands out as one of the most skilled forwards in this year’s draft class. His offensive production speaks for itself, as he blends creativity, quick hands, and excellent hockey sense to consistently generate scoring chances. He’s a dynamic presence in the offensive zone and excels in tight spaces, making him a constant threat whenever he has the puck.

An added bonus is his Quebec roots, which naturally align with the cultural identity of the Canadiens. While there’s a valid argument that Carbonneau’s profile may overlap with existing pieces in Montreal’s forward core—particularly in terms of size and playing style—the organization has historically prioritized talent and upside over fit, especially when given the flexibility of multiple first-round selections.

Owning back-to-back picks gives the Canadiens the luxury to swing on pure skill, and Carbonneau fits that mold perfectly. He may not address a positional or stylistic need immediately, but his high ceiling makes him a worthwhile investment for a team looking to add offensive flair. If he continues to round out his game and translate his scoring touch to the next level, Carbonneau could become a valuable piece of Montreal’s long-term offensive structure.

“Carbonneau is a right-shot forward with a shoot-first mentality and an instinctive knack for scoring. Featured on the top line and first power-play unit, he thrives on the left flank, where he eagerly sets up for his one-timer—a heavy, NHL-caliber shot that he doesn’t hesitate to unleash whenever he’s inside the blue line. Offensively, his game revolves around his shot; rarely does he pass that up. However, he can also use his frame effectively in puck battles, outmuscling defenders and driving play toward the net for second-chance looks. He’s got soft hands in tight, capable of adjusting his release point or finding a different angle under pressure. When engaged and moving his feet, his skating is more than adequate and allows him to be a force in the offensive zone. His passing game is solid, with good vision of where his teammates are, but if he’s in the offensive zone, chances are he is shooting.” – FCHockey crossover scout Jonathan Cottone

17. MONTREAL CANADIENS: JACK NESBITT | C | WINDSOR (OHL)

The Canadiens select Jack Nesbitt of the Windsor Spitfires with the 17th pick in the 2025 NHL Draft.

Adding size down the middle is a sensible move for an organization that already boasts several skilled, smaller forwards. Nesbitt brings a more physical, two-way element to the Canadiens’ prospect pool and projects as a player who can complement their existing core with a different style of play.

While his long-term ceiling may not be as high as some of the more offensively gifted centers in the class, Nesbitt offers reliability, work ethic, and strong defensive instincts—traits that translate well to a third-line role at the NHL level. He’s effective in the faceoff circle, competes hard on every shift, and doesn’t shy away from physical play. His ability to kill penalties and match up against opposing top lines adds value beyond the scoresheet.

This pick represents a thoughtful balance between drafting for upside and addressing organizational structure. With Carbonneau already added to bolster offensive skill, bringing in Nesbitt gives Montreal a more complete look at center moving forward. It’s a pragmatic choice that could pay dividends in building out the kind of depth needed for sustained success.

“During his second OHL season, Nesbitt has taken a significant leap forward in his development and is regularly deployed on Windsor’s top power-play unit and penalty kill. He is a highly effective net-front presence, tough to contain, and positions himself around the net to jar pucks loose and capitalize on rebounds. Defensively, Nesbitt demonstrates a strong understanding of positioning and uses his long reach to disrupt plays and transition the puck up ice. He will need to improve his first-step acceleration and refine his puck management skills to further elevate his game.” – Kennedy

18. CALGARY FLAMES (VIA NJD): COLE RESCHNY | C | VICTORIA (WHL)

The Calgary Flames select Cole Reschny of the Victoria Royals with the 18th pick in the 2025 NHL Draft.

Following a surprisingly competitive season, the Flames enter the draft with two first-round picks and a clearly defined organizational need down the middle. While they’ve done an excellent job stockpiling talent on the blue line—highlighted by Zayne Parekh—and boast a franchise goaltender in Dustin Wolf, as well as quality skill on the wings, the depth at center remains thin. This is where Reschny becomes a compelling fit.

Though undersized, Reschny plays with the kind of motor and competitiveness that allows him to remain effective at center. His offensive game has continued to evolve, showcasing high-end playmaking vision and a more assertive scoring touch as the season progressed. While his first half was somewhat underwhelming, he turned a corner after the new year, stringing together strong performances in the WHL playoffs and at the U18 World Championship.

Reschny brings creativity, quickness, and a willingness to battle in all areas of the ice. He may never be a prototypical top-line center, but his skill set and tenacity project favorably as a high-end middle-six option who can drive offense and play responsibly. For Calgary, a team already building a promising foundation, Reschny represents a smart swing on a player who addresses a key need while offering significant upside.

“His positioning is consistently on point, allowing him to maximize his impact by anticipating the flow of play. I particularly admire his instincts as a trailer on the rush; he expertly positions himself to stay open as a passing target while creating the most time and space to make a play when he gets the puck. As a puck carrier, he demonstrates balance in knowing when to attack the net himself and when to defer. While he’s further along as a playmaker, he’s steadily improving at capitalizing on his own scoring opportunities. His passing ability is exceptional, characterized by cross-ice vision and a refined touch on both his forehand and backhand.” – FCHockey chief regional scout Donesh Mazloum

19. ST. LOUIS BLUES: CAMERON REID | D | KITCHENER (OHL)

The St. Louis Blues select Cameron Reid of the Kitchener Rangers with the 19th pick of the 2025 NHL Draft.

Reid isn’t the flashiest player in this draft class, but he brings a level of efficiency and consistency that’s hard to overlook. His skating is smooth and well-balanced, allowing him to transition the puck effectively and maintain strong positioning in both ends of the ice. While he doesn’t often make the highlight reel, his ability to execute clean exits, manage pressure, and make smart decisions under duress makes him a dependable presence on the back end.

He rarely forces plays or overextends, instead relying on high hockey IQ and composure to keep things simple and effective. Reid’s game is built on reliability—he limits mistakes, stays within his structure, and quietly contributes in all three zones. Whether it’s moving the puck out of danger, supporting the attack with timely pinches, or breaking up entries with good stick positioning, he consistently does the little things right.

Because of this well-rounded and mature style, Reid projects as a plug-and-play defenseman who could fit seamlessly into any NHL lineup, regardless of the team’s system or style. He may not have the high ceiling of some of his peers, but his floor is among the highest in the class. For teams looking for stability and low-maintenance effectiveness on the blue line, Reid offers exactly that.

“Reid is a very smart, smooth-skating defenseman who uses his mobility and quick processing ability to make a positive impact at both ends of the ice despite lacking the physicality of other big-minute defenders. He is an excellent skater with strong four-way mobility, using his agility to create space from opposing players and find lanes in the offensive zone. While he doesn’t have elite top-end speed, he compensates with great anticipation and positional awareness, enabling him to defend rush chances and stop odd-man plays at his own blue line. Reid makes excellent decisions with the puck, utilizing his skating to exit the defensive zone quickly and carry the puck with control into the offensive end.” – Aleong

20. COLUMBUS BLUE JACKETS (VIA MIN): JOSHUA RAVENSBERGEN | G | PRINCE GEORGE (WHL)

The Blue Jackets select Joshua Ravensbergen of the Prince George Cougars with the 20th pick in the 2025 NHL Draft.

Ravensbergen is widely expected to be the first goaltender selected in this year’s draft, and despite some inconsistencies in his play, he validates a first-round selection based on his overall profile and upside. At 6-foot-5, he possesses the prototypical size for a modern NHL netminder, and it’s complemented by excellent athleticism and refined technical mechanics. His lateral movement is strong, his tracking is sharp when he’s dialed in, and he shows the kind of poise under pressure that’s essential at the next level.

While he has experienced stretches of uneven performance, particularly in high-traffic games, his peaks are highly impressive and reflective of a goaltender with legitimate No. 1 potential. The raw tools are in place; what he needs is continued refinement, experience, and strong development support to iron out the inconsistencies.

For Columbus, this feels like the right time to invest in a high-upside goalie. They already have Evan Gardner in the pipeline, but with two first-round picks and a well-stocked prospect pool at other positions, selecting Ravensbergen would address the long-term outlook in net. Goaltenders often take longer to develop, and by securing one now, the Blue Jackets can afford to be patient while potentially grooming their future starter. It’s a strategic, forward-thinking pick that balances organizational need with positional value.

“Ravensbergen’s frame and exceptional speed in the crease are what bring him to the top of most goalie lists. It’s hard to find a big goaltender who moves with the accuracy and pace that Ravensbergen pulls off in his crease. He carries both of these traits and also has very good positioning skills. He stays square to shooters and controls his angles well. Additionally, I really liked what I saw from Ravensbergen in regard to his ability to read net-front threats. He understands where those threats are and challenges or backs off from the shot location accordingly to make a back-door save as easy as possible.” – FCHockey chief goaltending scout David Phillips

21. OTTAWA SENATORS: BEN KINDEL | C | CALGARY (WHL)

The Ottawa Senators select Ben Kindel of the Calgary HItmen with the 21st pick in the 2025 NHL Draft.

Ottawa may ultimately not make this selection, given the pending forfeiture of a first-round pick over the next two drafts, but if they do, Kindel makes for a logical and high-upside choice. The Senators have an established connection to the Calgary Hitmen, having selected Carter Yakemchuk in the 2024 draft, which gives them a direct line of insight into Kindel’s season and development.

Kindel is among the most gifted playmakers in the class, showing elite vision, passing touch, and the ability to manipulate defenders to create space. While he’s a natural facilitator, he also owns a heavy, accurate one-timer that keeps defenders honest and gives him legitimate dual-threat scoring ability. His offensive production this season speaks volumes—leading all WHL draft eligibles with 35 goals and 64 assists for 99 points in 65 games.

While he’s been deployed at center at times, projecting him as a winger at the NHL level feels more realistic due to some concerns with his physical maturity, strength on pucks, and ability to consistently handle defensive responsibilities down the middle. That said, his offensive upside is undeniable, and in the right development environment, he could become a dynamic top-six winger capable of driving play and producing at a high rate.

For Ottawa, a team looking to round out its forward group with more skill and creativity, Kindel would be a strong addition—provided the pick is ultimately theirs to make.

“I’ve had the opportunity to watch Kindel live quite a bit this year and have gained an appreciation for how he creates offense. He’s an elite playmaker with the puck on his stick. He can make any type of pass consistently—whether it’s cross-seam passes, delicate saucer feeds, or dishes off his backhand, it doesn’t matter because odds are it’s going to reach its destination. The way he looks off certain teammates or deceives opponents opens up lanes for those passes, which speaks to how smart he is. The interesting part of his game is that without the puck, his primary threat is as a shooter. More specifically, he’s extremely dangerous with hard and accurate one-timers and quick snapshots when he can find space for his teammates to set him up.” – Elshafey

22. CALGARY FLAMES (VIA NJD): BRAEDEN COOTES | C | SEATTLE (WHL)

The Flames select Braeden Cootes of the Seattle Thunderbirds with the 22nd pick in the 2025 NHL Draft.

As mentioned, Calgary enters the draft with a clear organizational need down the middle, and after selecting Cole Reschny with their first pick, they wisely double down by taking Cootes with their second. While Cootes doesn’t possess the same offensive ceiling as Reschny, he brings a complementary skill set that adds valuable diversity to their center depth.

Cootes plays a heavy, north-south game with a nonstop motor, providing size, grit, and reliability in all three zones. He’s the type of player who wears opponents down with relentless forechecking, excels in puck battles, and doesn’t take shifts off. His right-handed shot adds a layer of utility, especially in faceoff situations and special teams deployment. Though he won’t drive offense in the same way more skilled pivots might, his defensive awareness and ability to play in high-effort matchups make him a strong candidate for a shutdown or energy role at the next level.

Given Calgary’s existing strength on the wings and on defense, coming away from the first round with two centers would be a strategic and necessary step toward long-term balance. Cootes might not garner headlines, but his game translates well to the demands of playoff hockey. For a Flames team looking to build a competitive core with a mix of skill and tenacity, this one-two punch down the middle is both logical and promising.

“Cootes is a two-way right-shot center with a blend of grit, skill, and compete. He’s an all-situations pivot who can play a tenacious game, is usually the first to arrive on loose pucks, and is willing to go to the hard areas of the offensive zone — not shy to plant himself in front of the opposition’s net. He doesn’t take too much time getting there, either, instead driving to the blue paint with his stick down on the ice for passes or deflections. Cootes zips passes with intention, and doesn’t second-guess his initial instinct when making a dish. He shows quick decision making when presented with little time and space in the offensive zone, and has a good sense of where his teammates are, or are going to be, on the attack. He has the ability to draw defenders in close to him before making a pass, though he doesn’t have dynamic stickhandling ability.” – Vickers

23. CAROLINA HURRICANES: CARTER BEAR | LW | EVERETT (WHL)

The Carolina Hurricanes select Carter Bear of the Everett Silvertips with the 23rd pick of the 2025 NHL Draft.

Bear started the season on an offensive tear, producing at an eye-catching rate before cooling off in the second half. That trajectory isn’t overly surprising, as his game doesn’t necessarily project as that of a high-end point producer at the NHL level. What Bear does offer, however, is a relentless motor, strong hockey sense, and an ability to make plays in high-traffic areas—qualities that hold significant value, particularly in playoff-style hockey.

He’s a good skater with respectable hands and vision, but much of his offense comes from his intelligence, timing, and work around the net. Whether it’s battling for loose pucks, tipping shots, or finding soft ice to make himself available, Bear consistently finds ways to contribute. While he’s played both center and wing, he projects more realistically as a winger at the next level, where his energy and tenacity can be maximized without the burden of full-time center responsibilities.

The Achilles injury he suffered is a legitimate concern and may cause him to slide slightly in the draft, but this range still feels appropriate based on his overall body of work. Carolina is an organization that places a premium on competitiveness, smart decision-making, and two-way responsibility—traits that align closely with Bear’s game. All told, Bear feels like a strong stylistic fit in Carolina’s system, offering depth, versatility, and the kind of intangible value the Hurricanes have long prioritized.

“His dynamic speed and agility allow him to be a constant presence on the ice, always moving in the offensive zone to find open ice and create chances. Bear’s ability to cut and change direction, combined with excellent hands, makes him elusive in tight spaces, and he pairs this with a physical edge, consistently finishing hits and engaging in battles. He is highly intelligent, often anticipating plays and predicting where defenders will be, which enables him to excel as an F3 and contribute effectively on both special teams. His passing is smart and accurate, complementing his offensive and defensive contributions.” – FCHockey crossover scout Kohen Willis Dengler

24. PHILADELPHIA FLYERS (VIA EDM): MALCOLM SPENCE | LW | ERIE (OHL)

The Flyers select Malcolm Spence of the Erie Otters with the 24th pick of the 2025 NHL Draft.

Spence began the year ranked higher on most draft boards but still brings several attractive qualities that keep him in the conversation as a valuable prospect. His combination of size and skill remains appealing, especially in a draft class where reliable physical forwards are at a premium. While his offensive output may have plateaued somewhat as the season progressed, his game is well-rounded enough to project into an NHL role, particularly in a bottom-six capacity.

He plays a straight-line, north-south style with an edge, and he’s not afraid to engage physically or throw his weight around on the forecheck. Spence handles the puck well in motion and can contribute offensively in spurts, but his long-term role likely centers on providing energy, playing responsible minutes, and wearing down opponents with his physicality and pace.

The Flyers would be a particularly fitting landing spot. Their organizational identity has long been associated with gritty, hard-nosed hockey, and Spence fits that mold to a tee. He brings the kind of effort, attitude, and physicality that Philadelphia fans appreciate, and could become a fan favorite if he carves out a role in their bottom six. While he may not have the ceiling of other forwards in his range, his floor is appealingly high, and his game seems tailor-made for the kind of depth role that teams lean on during playoff runs.

“Spence plays a mature, straightforward brand of hockey rooted in directness and physicality. Offensively, he shows a strong understanding of game flow, recognizing when to carry the puck in and when to chip and chase to get in hard on the forecheck. He navigates the dirty areas around the net effectively by staying in motion and competing for space, rather than simply parking himself. While not a flashy puckhandler, Spence protects the puck well and makes crisp passes with good timing and awareness, though his overall vision may be more functional than creative. His shot is a clear asset — he wastes no time releasing hard, accurate attempts that don’t linger on his stick. He does, however, need to improve his stick positioning in the offensive zone when he doesn’t have the puck.” – Vickers

25. PHILADELPHIA FLYERS (VIA COL): KURBAN LIMATOV | D | MHK DYNAMO MOSKVA (MHL)

The Flyers select Kurban Limatov of Dynamo Moskva with the 25th pick in the 2025 NHL Draft.

After selecting two forwards with their first two picks, the Flyers shift their focus to the blue line and head to Russia to select Limatov. He brings an enticing blend of size and mobility, traits that are increasingly sought after in modern NHL defensemen. Standing tall with strong skating mechanics, Limatov moves well in all directions and uses his reach effectively in defensive situations.

What stands out most in his game is his on-puck defending. He closes gaps efficiently, maintains strong stick positioning, and doesn’t panic under pressure. While his offensive upside remains somewhat limited, he makes smart, simple plays with the puck and can transition it effectively. His game isn’t flashy, but it’s dependable, and there’s room for growth if given time in the right development system.

Philadelphia has had a relatively positive track record with Russian prospects in recent years, and that familiarity likely makes this selection more comfortable. Adding a defenseman with Limatov’s physical and defensive tools brings balance to their draft class, especially after prioritizing forward depth early. He may take a few years before challenging for a roster spot, but his toolkit and style of play fit well with what the Flyers are building—a hard, structured team with strong foundational pieces. Limatov could eventually round out the right side of their defense corps with steadiness and physical maturity.

“He has a powerful skating stride and is able to reach a high top speed. Beyond his speed, he is very mobile for his size, skating well both backward and forward with impressive edge work. He is calm and collected with the puck and is able to find the tape of his teammates despite being under pressure. He is also capable of breaking out of his own zone by using his skating. He is strong and good at pushing opposing players up against the boards and retrieving the puck. He has an aggressive stick and is great at knocking the puck loose. I think his flaws lie in his game off the puck. He can sometimes position himself poorly when the other team is attacking on the rush. His decision-making on when to pressure players aggressively needs improvement.” – FCHockey regional scout Linus Johnsson

26. NASHVILLE PREDATORS (VIA TB): COLE MCKINNEY | C | USA U-18 (USNTDP)

ThePredators select Cole McKinney from the U.S National Development Program with the 26th pick in the 2025 NHL Draft.

McKinney plays with structure and purpose, rarely straying from his responsibilities and consistently making smart, low-risk decisions. He supports the puck well, forechecks effectively, and understands how to manage shifts without overcomplicating plays. He doesn’t shy away from contact, competes in all three zones, and shows enough skating ability to keep up with the pace of the pro game.

What stands out about McKinney is his maturity and reliability. He’s the type of player coaches trust, and while his ceiling may be limited to a bottom-six role, his floor is high for a late first-round pick. He projects as a player who can contribute on the penalty kill, provide energy, and chip in offensively when needed—essentially, the kind of low-maintenance depth forward that every successful NHL team needs.

In a part of the draft where upside often comes with risk, McKinney offers value through his predictability and pro-ready habits, making him a smart bet to eventually reach the NHL.

“McKinney is a two-way center who is comfortable playing in all situations. He is a strong skater, despite not being the fastest, with a wide base that makes it hard to knock him off the puck. His strong edgework allows him to change direction quickly. McKinney plays with a lot of intensity, forechecking hard and never shying away from contact or battles. His vision is particularly impressive. He isn’t an overly skilled player and keeps his game simple, lacking flashiness. While this makes him a dependable two-way option, it also caps his offensive upside.” – Roth

27. LOS ANGELES KINGS: SASCHA BOUMEDIENNE | D | BOSTON UNIVERSITY (NCAA)

The Los Angeles Kings select Sacha Boumedienne of Boston University with the 27th pick in the 2025 NHL Draft.

Boumedienne enters the first-round conversation on the strength of a historic U18 Worlds performance, where his point production from the back end turned heads. A smooth and agile skater, Boumedienne combines mobility with a calm presence on the puck, which allows him to navigate pressure and contribute effectively in transition. His skating forms the foundation of his game and was a key factor in his ability to adapt over the course of his freshman season in college hockey.

Though he may not project as a high-end offensive defenseman at the NHL level, Boumedienne’s skill set is still appealing. He makes smart, efficient plays, moves the puck well, and can run a second power-play unit if needed. His progression over the year suggests he’s coachable and able to adjust to higher levels of competition—an encouraging trait for a player transitioning to the pro ranks.

What makes Boumedienne intriguing is not just his international success, but how he steadily improved as the year went on in a challenging NCAA environment. That growth trajectory, paired with his skating and feel for the game, gives him the look of a reliable two-way defenseman. While his ceiling might be limited to a second-pairing role, the tools and development path put him firmly in first-round consideration, particularly for teams looking for mobility and composure on the blue line.

“His skating is great — quick, agile, and exceptionally smooth in backward motion. On the breakout, he uses his feet well to snap up retrievals and create separation from the first forechecker, allowing him to make a solid first pass to start the breakout. Defensively, his rush defense is already quite effective, largely due to his strong footwork and long reach. He positions himself well to disrupt plays and doesn’t often get caught out of position. While there’s a lot to like about his skating and transitional game, I don’t see huge upside in terms of his overall skill set. He’s not particularly dynamic or technically gifted beyond his skating and first pass.” – FCHockey crossover scout Greysen Goudy

28. SAN JOSE SHARKS (VIA DAL): LOGAN HENSLER | D | WISCONSIN (NCAA)

The Sharks select Logan Hensler of Wisconsin with the 28th pick of the 2025 NHL Draft.

The Sharks have assembled an impressive prospect pool in recent years, highlighted by high-end talent at forward and in goal, but the right side of their defense remains a clear area of need. Hensler fits that void well as a steady, right-shot defenseman who brings a dependable, no-frills game to the table. He’s a safe pick—one who may not possess elite upside but projects as the type of player every NHL team needs on its blue line.

Hensler defends with discipline and intelligence, maintaining strong gaps and showing excellent positioning in his own zone. He reads plays well, stays composed under pressure, and consistently makes smart decisions with the puck. While he isn’t going to rack up big offensive numbers, his mobility allows him to retrieve pucks efficiently and make clean zone exits, which is a critical trait for modern defensemen.

“Hensler is a puck-moving, two-way defender who plays a safe and consistent game. He brings stability to his own end, and coaches can rely on him in all situations, though his offensive output has been somewhat lacking this season. While he has never been a major offensive presence, I did expect a little more. What stands out is his overall presence—he plays safely, isn’t overly noticeable on the ice, but consistently does all the right things. He moves the puck extremely well and is a reliable presence on every shift. In this game, Hensler was once again consistent, reliable, and not particularly visible in a flashy way. He initiated many breakouts but rarely joined the attack in a meaningful way.” – Tirpak

29. CHICAGO BLACKHAWKS (VIA TOR): WILLIAM HORCOFF | C | MICHIGAN (NCAA)

The Blackhawks select William Horcoff from the University of Michigan with the 29th pick in the 2025 NHL Draft.

Horcoff made the transition from the NTDP to college hockey at Michigan this season, and his game has taken a noticeable step forward as a result. The elevated pace and physicality of the NCAA haven’t slowed him down—in fact, he’s looked more comfortable and engaged, particularly when playing to his strengths.

His size is the most obvious hallmark of his game, giving him a natural edge in board battles, net-front play, and defensive matchups. Horcoff uses his frame effectively to shield the puck and disrupt opponents, making him a reliable presence in all three zones. While he isn’t a dynamic offensive force at this stage, his puck protection, straight-line skating, and ability to support the play give him a solid foundation to build on.

“Horcoff is a power forward with exceptional size and details. He is able to be effective by winning puck battles and getting into the dirty areas to score and cause chaos for the defense. When Horcoff is at his best, he is an extremely effective forechecker and applies heavy pressure on the opposition in all three zones. In the offensive zone, he is able to recover dump-ins and gain possession for his team by being physical and has shown the ability to read the play extremely well. He is also a very good stick-checker and uses his reach to his advantage to cause turnovers. Horcoff is detail-oriented and effective away from the puck, showing a willingness to do the small things and, most importantly, support his teammates as an outlet. He doesn’t provide much as a playmaker off the carry but has shown the ability to play off the rush and make strong decisions.” – FCHockey crossover scout Nathan Hutchinson

30. NASHVILLE PREDATORS (VIA VGK): BLAKE FIDDLER | D | EDMONTON (WHL)

The Predators select Blake Fiddler of the Edmonton Oil Kings with the 30th pick in the 2025 NHL Draft.

Fiddler is a defenseman who plays a well-rounded, reliable game without standing out in any one particular area. He does a bit of everything—defends responsibly, moves the puck efficiently, and skates well enough to handle pace—but lacks a defining trait that truly separates him from his peers. While that can limit his upside, it also gives him a level of predictability that NHL teams often value.

There was some disappointment in his offensive development this season. Expectations were higher in terms of production and assertiveness with the puck, but Fiddler didn’t quite take that next step. His decision-making remained sound, but there was a noticeable lack of growth in his ability to drive play or quarterback the offense, which slightly dampens his ceiling as a potential top-four option.

That said, Fiddler’s value lies in his stability. He rarely makes many mistakes, processes the game at a high level, and plays within his means. These are qualities that can translate well to a depth role at the professional level.

“He has a long stick that he uses to disrupt passes or shots, reads and anticipates plays really well, and maintains the right gap to prevent forwards from beating him to the inside while staying close enough to use his stick to disrupt the play. Fiddler’s straight-line speed is impressive for his size, but I find his ability to move laterally — with turns, edges, and changes of direction — a bit slow. In general, though, his mobility is a strength, and he even uses it to join or lead the rush from time to time. Fiddler isn’t the most physical 6-foot-4 player you’ve ever seen, but he separates the man from the puck effectively and does the important things like block shots and move around the defensive zone in a positionally sound way.”

“While there isn’t an area of his game that’s a glaring weakness, the lack of elite qualities means there’s a ceiling on his potential. Additionally, I haven’t seen noticeable strides in improvement throughout the year, so I wouldn’t classify him as a prospect trending upward. That said, his high floor keeps his stock from dropping.” – Elshafey

31. WASHINGTON CAPITALS: JACK MURTAGH | C | USA U-18 (USNTDP)

The Washington Capitals select Jack Murtagh from the U.S National Development Program with the 31st pick of the 2025 NHL Draft.

Much like several of his peers from this year’s NTDP, Murtagh may not possess a particularly high ceiling, but he brings a well-rounded, responsible game that could translate effectively to the NHL. He plays with structure and intelligence, showing a strong understanding of positioning and situational awareness—especially in tight-checking, low-space environments that mirror the demands of pro-level hockey.

His comfort in physical, tightly contested games is one of his most projectable traits. He doesn’t panic under duress and plays a north-south style that allows him to be effective in a variety of roles. Whether as a checking-line winger or a depth piece who can chip in with smart, mistake-free minutes, Murtagh has the kind of mature, system-friendly game that NHL teams often look for in the later stages of the first round of the draft.

“While he didn’t stand out as an elite stickhandler, he showcased quick hands to avoid stick checks, extend plays, and move the puck into better areas. His shot carries a lot of power, especially on his one-timers. Away from the puck, he positions himself well in open space and occasionally goes to the net front to serve as a screen. Overall, he is a well-rounded offensive player both with and without the puck.” – Pereira

32. WINNIPEG JETS: BILL ZONNON | LW | ROUYN-NORANDA (QMJHL)

The Winnipeg Jets select Bill Zonnon of the Rouyn-Noranda Huskies with the 32nd pick in the 2025 NHL Draft.

Zonnon is a tall, lanky playmaker whose offensive game stands out among players projected in this range of the draft. With 28 goals and 55 assists in 64 games, he brings a clear scoring pedigree and high-end vision that makes him a legitimate threat whenever the puck is on his stick. His ability to find seams, manipulate defenders, and distribute the puck with precision sets him apart as one of the more offensively gifted players still available.

Though not known for his physicality, Zonnon’s size still works to his advantage. He uses his reach effectively to protect the puck and maintain possession in tight areas, and while he won’t overpower opponents, his length allows him to navigate through traffic and create space for himself and his teammates. His skating is adequate, and paired with his puck skills, he consistently drives offense in the offensive zone.

“A natural playmaker, Zonnon remains poised with the puck, displaying superior vision and delivering precise, firm passes to his teammates with ease, even under heavy pressure. He thrives at finding teammates in shooting lanes and setting up redirections. Zonnon is also a strong presence in front of and around the net, securing high-danger spots and proving difficult to move. He circulates the puck well in the offensive zone and shows the ability to transition from the boards to the interior, unleashing hard shots on net. However, I wouldn’t consider Zonnon a threatening scorer, as his shot lacks significant danger, and he primarily scores by driving the net and capitalizing on second chances.” – Boulay

OTHER DEEP DIVES YOU MIGHT LIKE: